Premier League news: Caretaker or contender – Manchester United’s latest managerial dilemma
One week on from Ruben Amorim’s departure, Manchester United once again find themselves searching for short-term stability amid long-term uncertainty.
With the season itself unravelling, the Red Devils are expected to appoint a caretaker manager until the summer, writes Sports News Blitz’s Alex Rhodes.
Two candidates have emerged as the frontrunners for the role: former United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjær and ex-midfielder Michael Carrick, with the latter believed to be the preferred option.
Darren Fletcher, the club’s current interim manager, was also considered for the role on a permanent basis.
However, a disappointing 2-2 draw against relegation-threatened Burnley followed by a 2-1 defeat to Brighton in the FA Cup has done little to strengthen his case.
Those results mean the Red Devils are set for their shortest campaign (40 games) since the 1914/15 season, when competition was curtailed by the outbreak of World War One.
This also marks the first season since 1981/82 that the club has been eliminated in the opening round of both domestic competitions.
Carrick: The short-term solution
On paper, Carrick’s appointment appears a sensible, low-risk choice.
The former England midfielder played 464 games for United between 2006 and 2018 after joining from Tottenham Hotspur.
Following his retirement in 2018, Carrick transitioned into coaching, joining José Mourinho’s backroom staff before later working under Solskjær for 168 matches.
When the Norwegian was dismissed in 2021, Carrick oversaw three matches, winning two and drawing one, before Ralf Rangnick took charge.
Two and a half seasons at Championship club Middlesbrough followed for Carrick.
In 2023, he guided the club to the play-offs, where they lost to Coventry 1-0 in the semi-finals.
Narrowly failing to reach the play-offs in the next two seasons proved costly and Carrick was sacked shortly after.
While this experience has added resilience, there are doubts that he is sufficiently prepared for the demands of Premier League management.
READ MORE: FA Cup news: Man Utd dumped out by Brighton as interim manager Darren Fletcher awaits first win
What does Man United need in a manager?
Suitability has become a recurring question at Old Trafford.
Former United defender Gary Neville outlined his criteria in an online newsletter, highlighting the challenges attached to the role.
“You have to be able to handle the media and the noise that comes with this club,” wrote Neville on Sky Sports.
“You have to show you can have success getting into the top four … and you can get the best out of a group of players that will include egos and superstars.
“You have to understand the Manchester United way … to be positive and prepared to take risks.
“They must understand Premier League and English Football culture.”
Neville’s assessment of United’s situation highlights that tactical innovation is not enough – emotional and cultural change are also required.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: FA Cup news: Winners and losers from the third round as Macclesfield upset holders Crystal Palace
Long-term candidates: Ancelotti, Tuchel, Howe
If those criteria were taken at face value, the so-called ‘natural successor’ is current Brazil manager Carlo Ancelotti.
The Italian held discussions in 2013 with the club as Sir Alex Ferguson’s replacement; however, he opted to join Spanish giants Real Madrid instead.
Although his experience in English football has been limited, it has been impressive.
In two seasons with Chelsea, winning the Premier League was a highlight, followed by a year and a half with Everton up until 2021, where he showcased his ability to stabilise a team and develop its players.
Thomas Tuchel has also been linked with the role.
An experienced manager with successful Champions League, Bundesliga and Ligue 1 campaigns, he would bring United elite pedigree and tactical depth.
His Premier League experience managing Chelsea demonstrated his natural ability to adapt to English football as well as a constant desire to win.
Eddie Howe, meanwhile, offers a different skill set.
Having spent nine seasons managing in the top flight with Bournemouth and Newcastle, Howe understands the league and the dynamics of English football.
His work at Newcastle, which includes Champions League qualification and a historic trophy win at Wembley, suggests he has all the acumen required for the role.
READ NEXT: FA Cup news: Aston Villa outclass Tottenham in North London to advance into the fourth round
Learning from past mistakes
Manchester United’s recent managerial issues have been caused by chasing ‘exciting’ managers over experienced ones.
Appointments such as Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim represented the club’s ambition, but both lacked experience in Europe’s most competitive leagues.
Gary Lineker, speaking on The Rest is Football podcast, reflected on Amorim’s tenure, saying: “It didn’t seem to be the right fit, and he was a bit stubborn about the way he wanted to play.”
Despite ongoing instability behind the scenes, the United job remains one of football’s most coveted positions.
Jamie Carragher, former Liverpool player, described the role as an “attractive job” for “any manager”, highlighting the club’s potential moving forward rather than its recent shortcomings.
Former United first-team coach, René Meulensteen, echoed this, stressing the importance of character as much as tactics.
“They need someone with pedigree,” he said. “Somebody with a strong personality, strong charisma.”
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN: Newcastle news: Harvey Barnes v Anthony Gordon – Who should Eddie Howe start on the left wing?
United’s dilemma: Stability or identity?
Manchester United now face an all too familiar crossroads.
A caretaker appointment like Carrick may steady the ship but does nothing to address the club’s deeper crisis.
Until the club can define their true values, no manager will offer the innovation and understanding the team currently requires.
The next decision the club makes is thus crucial – it must represent a willingness to learn from its past, rather than repeating it.
TRANSFER NEWS: Transfer news: Antoine Semenyo completes £65m move to Manchester City from Bournemouth
