Soccer opinion: Is officiating ruining the Premier League as a product and spectacle?

As we approach the business end of a season in which officiating, and the controversies surrounding it, have taken the headlines almost weekly in the Premier League.

I felt it was time to take a look at how the past few weeks have sent a certain club’s fanbase to boiling point, as mistakes continue to be made by those refereeing football at the highest-possible level. 

Sports News Blitz writer Charlie Fawcett takes a deep dive into how Leeds United and their supporters have been affected by “ambiguous” refereeing decisions so far in 2026. 

I, and many other die-hard supporters of football clubs up and down the country, have all been having very similar conversations so far this season. 

Whether that be on the train to the match, or just in the workplace, the message is clear that for many of us, we have never felt more detached and almost borderline uninterested in the sport as we are right now. 

The argument can be made that this is due to the shift towards a much more physical and set-piece orientated style, however, I feel that for many of us, the lack of consistency from officials is making going to the football feel more and more like an unpleasant experience. 

Leeds United v Manchester City

I am going to look at this through the perspective of a recent high-profile Premier League game, which, for many, was ultimately tarnished by poor refereeing. 

Kicking off with their game against Man City on February 28. 

As Leeds chased an equaliser to level the game at 1-1, fury took over the Elland Road crowd as a cross was launched into the box, and seemingly cleared away from Dominic Calvert-Lewin via a diversion from Matheus Nunes’ arm. 

Despite the arm moving in the direction of the ball, the appeals were waved away by Peter Bankes, who judged the City attacker’s arm to have been in a natural position. 

Furthermore, there was more frustration attached to this particular contest, as Rayan Cherki appeared to stamp on the Leeds number 44 Ilia Gruev, down by the corner flag by where the Manchester City supporters were housed, which was also missed by the officials. 

Finally, to rub salt in very prominent wounds, despite both managers reacting very emotionally throughout, as Daniel Farke ran over to discuss the match with Bankes, he was handed a red card before even reaching the man in the middle, further sparking pure rage within the stands. 

What needs to be changed to make a better product? 

In terms of how the Premier League can improve for its match-going supporters, I think that VAR decisions must be communicated better to those in the stadium.

I believe that replays of the incident at hand being played within stadiums would help massively to reduce the frustrations from supporters.

Whereas in the current game, they are left completely in the dark until the moment the final decision is made. 

I also think that there is a dire need in a reduction of buzz-words being used, many viewers are sick to the back teeth of hearing phrases such as “clear and obvious error” or “natural/unnatural position” because despite this jargon being used, decisions are completely inconsistent. 

This all once again leads to the feeling of detachment, as many fans are beginning to feel that if so many calls are massively ambiguous, there is simply no point anymore, as it is impossible to predict whether a call will go a certain way.

READ MORE: WATCH! Pole Position podcast - Mercedes vs Ferrari, Australian GP and Chinese GP madness, and more

Is the decline in interest down to officiating? 

It of course can be argued that officiating is the be all and end all to this problem, but I think there is far more nuance in the bigger picture.

Whether you come at this issue through the angle of refereeing, the shift in style to a much more calculated and set-piece orientated approach, or even just the fact that Premier League football now prioritises TV fans in such a huge way.

It is clear to see why supporters are feeling not just detached from the sport, but are also feeling almost abandoned by their own clubs.

READ NEXT: Premier League analysis: Five talking points from Crystal Palace v Leeds United